Every year, many students who have overcome daunting obstacles in high school receive good news — they've been accepted to college.
These kids represent a success story: through hard work and determination, they've made into college, and perhaps even on to a better life.
Except it doesn't always work out that way.
"The rate with which kids who are college-intending do not actually get to college in the fall is surprisingly high," says Lindsay Page, an education researcher at the University of Pittsburgh. "In one sample that we looked at in the Boston area, we find that upwards of 20% of kids who at the time of high school graduation say that they're continuing on to college — about 20% of those kids don't actually show up in the fall."
Researchers call this phenomenon "summer melt" — and for universities, it has long been a puzzling problem. Because these are the kids who made it: they've taken the SATs, been accepted to a college of their choice, applied for and received financial aid. Why wouldn't they show up for college on day one?
This week on Hidden Brain, we explore this problem, and how one university is working to fix it.
The Hidden Brain Podcast is hosted by Shankar Vedantam and produced by Maggie Penman, Jennifer Schmidt, Renee Klahr, Rhaina Cohen, Parth Shah, and Lucy Perkins. Our supervising producer is Tara Boyle. You can also follow us on Twitter @hiddenbrain, and listen for Hidden Brain stories each week on your local public radio station.
SHANKAR VEDANTAM (HOST): This is HIDDEN BRAIN. I'm Shankar Vedantam. Every year, many students who have overcome daunting obstacles in high school receive good news - they've been accepted to college. Many of them are low-income students with outstanding academic track records. And they represent a success story - the American dream made real. With hard work, students who don't have a lot of advantages can bootstrap their way into higher education and a better life. Only, it doesn't always work out.
LINDSAY PAGE (HARVARD UNIVERSITY): The rate with which kids who are college-intending do not actually get to college in the fall is surprisingly high.
VEDANTAM: This is Lindsay Page, an education researcher at Harvard.
PAGE: In one sample that we look at in the Boston area, we find that upwards of 20 percent of kids who, at the time of high school graduation, say they're continuing on to college - about 20 percent of those kids don't actually show up in the fall.
VEDANTAM: Twenty percent - among low-income kids, that number is even higher. They're getting tripped up somehow right at the finish line. Researchers call this phenomenon summer melt. For universities, it's long been a puzzling problem because these are the kids who made it. They took the SATs. They got good grades. They took AP classes. They did their extracurricular activities. They wrote their college essays. They've often applied for and received financial aid. Why wouldn't they show up at college?
PAGE: In the summer between high school graduation and what would be timely college matriculation, they're falling off track.
VEDANTAM: This week on HIDDEN BRAIN, the problem of the last mile and how to fix it.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
AUSTIN BIRTUL: Hello, I'm Austin Birtul (ph). I'm a rising sophomore at Georgia State University.
VEDANTAM: Austin grew up in a working-class family about an hour outside of Atlanta. And from a very young age, he saw college as his ticket to a better life.
BIRTUL: Growing up, my father worked at a produce stand. He opened a produce stand once he got out of the military. And my mom was an assistant manager at a jewelry store.
VEDANTAM: Neither of Austin's parents went to college. And Austin saw how hard it was for them even to get jobs in retail or the service industry without a college degree. Austin was an excellent student and a good planner. He took advanced placement classes to help his GPA and to get college credits out of the way. He kept his sights firmly on college in spite of a number of challenges. His dad got sick while he was still in school.
BIRTUL: It was a lot of studying, late nights. The first half of my high school, I was coming home and doing homework while taking care of my dad.
VEDANTAM: Austin's dad had ALS, also known as Lou Gehrig's disease.
BIRTUL: So my mom would take care of him during the day. And I would come home from school and take care of him at night. That's kind of how we did it.
VEDANTAM: Austin's dad passed away at the end of his sophomore year of high school. And his mom, who had quit her job at the jewelry store when he got sick, had to find work again.
BIRTUL: Here she was on the job market trying to become employed. And she hadn't gone to college. I'm a first-generation student to go to college. And she saw what the market was like when not having a college degree.
VEDANTAM: There was one conversation with his mother that stuck in Austin's head.
BIRTUL: I remember sitting in the kitchen. And she had just sent out a bunch of resumes and not getting any calls back. And she really just sat me down and said, this is something you're going to have to do.
VEDANTAM: He had to go to college, so he redoubled his commitment. And he figured out where he wanted to go. He visited Georgia State, a large public university in the heart of Atlanta.
BIRTUL: I decided I was going to go to Georgia State very early on in the process. I took a tour here. I loved the inner-city school and looking up at the skyscrapers in the middle of Atlanta and thinking, how is a school campus here? And there was just all these, like, new buildings and all these people walking around with backpacks and going to their classes. And I wanted this college to be my college.
VEDANTAM: It seemed like the perfect fit - not too far from home. He knew he couldn't afford the tuition, but he figured he had a solution.
BIRTUL: So I knew that Zell Miller is the scholarship we have here in Georgia to pay for most of your tuition. I knew I needed that. So my entire high school curriculum, like, I pushed myself to get that scholarship.
VEDANTAM: The Zell Miller would cover most of his tuition, about 90 percent. His father had been in the military, so the GI Bill would help out with the rest. And then a little bit of financial aid from the university could cover housing and other expenses.
So Austin applied, not only for college, but also for all the aid he needed. Around Christmas, he learned that all his hard work and sacrifice had paid off. He'd gotten into his dream school.
BIRTUL: They didn't do a letter. They did this like thing you open up, and it says you're accepted. It was a really great feeling. I turned to my mom, and she got all teary-eyed. And it was a great time (laughter).
VEDANTAM: He had the grades and the SAT scores for the scholarship he needed.
BIRTUL: So I'd filled out the housing. I'd done my deposit for housing. I got my immunizations done.
VEDANTAM: Everything was coming together. And then suddenly, he discovered there was a problem.
BIRTUL: Somewhere along the way, I found out my Social Security number had been written down wrong somewhere through the system. And I wasn't receiving the scholarship that I had worked so hard for.
VEDANTAM: Austin had checked all the boxes, met all the deadlines, done everything right. Like Austin, lots of kids get tripped up right at the finish line.
We're going to come back to Austin's story. But first, let's look at the other side of the equation - the university admissions office.
SCOTT BURKE (GEORGIA STATE UNIVERSITY): So I'm Scott Burke. And I'm the associate vice president and director of undergraduate admissions for Georgia State University in Atlanta, Ga.
VEDANTAM: Scott couldn't figure out why so many promising students who were admitted to the university were not showing up on day one. And the problem was getting worse.
BURKE: We began to see a creep in the number of students that were not attending in the fall, that were at some point in that pre-enrollment process falling off.
VEDANTAM: Scott thought maybe these kids are the ones who are the least committed, the least academically prepared. But then he looked more closely at the data. He found students like Austin Birtul.
BURKE: And what we found is, overall, these were good, academically qualified students with, in many cases, 3.5 GPAs, 1,100 SAT scores that, for whatever reason, were just not able to continue on with the process.
VEDANTAM: Scott had a feeling that the problem might be the challenges of the reams of paperwork students had to fill out before getting to college.
BURKE: We have - roughly, about 35 percent of our population is first-generation college students. They don't necessarily have the support that they need to go through that enrollment process in the way that a non-first-generation student would have somebody at home that could help them really guide them through that. They don't necessarily have the same peer group that allows them or helps them to - supports them to assist them.
VEDANTAM: Scott Burke knew all too well how much showing up on day one mattered.
BURKE: I mean, this is about changing lives. You know, I'm a first-generation college student. I was the first in my family to go to college. I was the first in my family to achieve a master's degree. And it has meant, you know, for me, a better quality of life.
So to see students not ending up somewhere was a real concern for us because as we looked at the data, as we looked at the information and the analytics that was in front of us, there was a large percentage of students that weren't ending up going anywhere, obviously. And that was a major concern. It wasn't that we were losing them to other colleges or universities, it was that they were not ending up anywhere.
VEDANTAM: Scott wanted to find a way to fix the problem.
Lindsay Page, the education researcher at Harvard, says the problem wasn't just at Georgia State.
PAGE: The rate with which kids who are college-intending do not actually get to college in the fall is surprisingly high. So in one sample that we look at in the Boston area, we find that upwards of 20 percent of kids who at the time of high school graduation say that they're continuing on to college, about 20 percent of those kids don't actually show up in the fall. And with other data sources, we've looked at these patterns nationally and find that rates can range from about 10 percent to 40 percent, but we see similar patterns wherever we look across the country.
VEDANTAM: Did you hear that? In some communities, 40 percent of college-bound kids don't go. And rates of summer melt are highest for kids from lower-income backgrounds, especially if their own parents didn't go through the college application process.
Lindsay's colleague Ben Castleman says students without a lot of family support can find themselves at a disadvantage.
BEN CASTLEMAN (UNIVERSITY OF HARVARD): Students from middle or upper-income backgrounds often have college-educated parents who are familiar with the process and can help guide them through it. If students are the first in their family to go to college, their parents may not have experience with or confidence in completing financial aid paperwork or completing the various tasks that colleges require of students. And at the same time, students often don't have access to professional help. Their high school counselors typically don't work during the summer. They've yet to engage with supports at their college. And so there's a wide range of complex tasks that students need to complete at a time when they often don't have access to support.
VEDANTAM: Unfortunately, the financial-aid process is far from simple. Many students run into problems even earlier in the process than Austin did.
CASTLEMAN: So if you put yourself in the mind of an 18-year-old who's the first in their family to go to college, imagine that you open the mail and you receive a financial aid award letter. And that's going to determine what aid you receive and whether you can afford college. Well, you need to be able to look at that award letter and distinguish grant aid from the college or from the state or federal government that you won't need to pay back from loan aid that you will have to pay back over time. And you have to add both of those together, figure out how they relate to the total cost of attendance at whichever institution you're planning to enroll at.
Depending on the institution, financial aid award letters are often hard to read and hard to digest even for college-educated people. And so for that student who doesn't have access to professional help, they may have a hard time separating out, how much am I getting in free money? How much am I going to have to pay back? Does this aid really cover the full cost of enrolling where I want to go to college? And so a month later when they get their tuition bill, the student may be surprised to find that they're going to have to send a check or, in some way, pay the college considerably more money or have to take out a considerably larger amount of loans than they realized, certainly, at the end of high school and maybe even at the start of summer.
VEDANTAM: Obviously, failing to show up at college is a huge deal for the individual student. It can change the course of their life. But Ben says there are also huge societal costs.
CASTLEMAN: From when students enter kindergarten through when they graduate high school, we as a society invest hundreds of thousands of dollars in their academic success. For the students that we're focusing on, that investment has in many ways paid off in that they have applied to and been accepted to college. And they decide where to enroll. And they've graduated high school. By making a small additional investment during the summer to help students overcome those tasks, we can make good on the investment we've already made and continue students on the path to academic and professional success.
VEDANTAM: Lindsay and Ben wrote a book together about summer melt. They wanted to find a university to test an intervention they had in mind. At Georgia State, Scott Burke read that book.
BURKE: And I said, we have to be that institution.
VEDANTAM: Stay with us.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
VEDANTAM: This is HIDDEN BRAIN. I'm Shankar Vedantam. Scott Burke and his colleagues at Georgia State University had a problem. A number of students who said they were planning to attend the school were failing to show up on day one. And that number was going up.
BURKE: So when I first arrived at Georgia State, we were at about a 12 percent melt rate. And at its height last year, we were at 18 percent.
VEDANTAM: Scott was at a loss. The school could have hired more administrators to address all the challenges students faced over the summer. But to serve such a large body of students, it would have been very expensive. They tried emailing the students with reminders, but that didn't fix the problem.
BURKE: We knew that we were missing in our toolbox the ability to be able to nudge students to do things and then for us to be able to actually get some engagement and correspondence back from that student as to maybe why they weren't doing it, what was the barrier in place.
VEDANTAM: The social science question here is, how do you, in a low cost way, help students get through the essential tasks in time? How do you give them access to support without lots of additional administrators?
With the help of Lindsay Page, Georgia State came up with a surprisingly simple solution. They developed an artificially intelligent chatbot named Pounce after the school's mascot, a blue panther. The school wanted to do more than simply introduce an intervention. It wanted to test if the intervention worked. So administrators conducted an experiment. Half the incoming students would get text messages from Pounce, the other half would not.
BURKE: So what we wanted to do was to measure the impact of the chatbot on the pre-enrollment process. And would it make a difference for those students that had the opportunity to engage with him - with Pounce? We would begin pushing out nudges to students who didn't do things as a part of the pre-enrollment process.
VEDANTAM: From there, the idea was that students could ask Pounce questions as they came up. Let's say Pounce messaged a student to tell her the school hadn't received her financial aid application, also known as a FAFSA form.
BURKE: And then what that allowed the student to do is from a natural curiosity standpoint - well, wait a minute, I actually did submit my FAFSA. Something must be going on here. And that's when the student can begin asking other questions. When is financial aid supposed to post? When am I supposed to receive my financial aid award? So it allowed the student to take the conversation further. And it allowed the student to get faster responses from Pounce than they would have if they had just emailed that question.
Or if they had called the university, they might have sat on hold. Depending upon the volume of our calls that particular day, they might have sat on hold for 30 or 40 minutes before they could get a response to their question. So Pounce allowed us - the chatbot allowed us to have students engaging with him and getting responses much more quickly than they would of if they tried to do one of those other traditional ways.
VEDANTAM: The chatbot worked even better than the administrators expected. It could answer about 90 percent of the student's questions. And when it couldn't answer something, a human being would step in, do the research and get back to the student. From that point on, Pounce would learn the correct answer to the question and respond to other students who had the same question. The university saw results for students who had the opportunity to chat with Pounce.
BURKE: We found 3 percentage points less likely to have a FAFSA verification hold on their account. We found 4 percentage points more likely to submit a final high school transcript. We had 3 percentage points of the group attend orientation. So a lot of the pre-enrollment checklist things that we were monitoring, we were finding that the group that was engaging with Pounce was doing these things actually at a higher percentage. Submitting their immunizations - 5 percentage points more likely to submit an immunization, register for classes, complete the loan entrance counseling, complete their master promissory notes. We found a 6 to 7 percent increase in the students in that group completing these very important checklist items.
VEDANTAM: These are small numbers but they add up.
BURKE: For fall 2015, we had 3,400 students enroll. For fall 2016, We had over 3,700 students. So that meant 300 more students than we had the year before. And we reduced our summer melt from 18 percent down to 14 percent.
VEDANTAM: That 4 percentage-point difference meant an increase in 300 students who showed up at school on day one. One of the students who heard from Pounce was Austin Birtul.
BIRTUL: I'm very much a people person. And so I like to maybe, like, harass the person and be like, hey, can I get this fixed? But it actually was a little simpler because it's this faster response. It's not somebody going to their higher-up and asking questions. It's this fast response. And you get the answers you need really quickly. And you don't feel this maybe like embarrassment that it hasn't been done, you know, because it's just a robot.
VEDANTAM: Many 17 and 18-year-old kids don't want to ask questions they're supposed to know the answer to already. It's embarrassing.
BIRTUL: If you haven't been able to figure out something, you kind of want to - you want to be able to say you figured it out. And so to have an issue and it be - and you be - it feels like you're doing it yourself when a robot's helping you. It's like a tool. While, like, if you're having to rely on somebody else. It creates a sense of dependency.
VEDANTAM: Pounce reached out to Austin in April and offered to be helpful. When Austin got nervous that his financial aid had not come through, he reached out to the chatbot.
BIRTUL: Pounce gave me dates when it would be applied. Pounce told me to go to the FAFSA website to check. And Pounce told me to alert the financial aid office.
VEDANTAM: Austin learned the problem was that his Social Security number had been entered incorrectly.
BIRTUL: It was off by one number.
VEDANTAM: The chatbot advised him to come down to campus to look into the problem. Austin didn't know where to go at the school. Pounce had the answer to that question, too. So Austin got on a bus and came to the university. Within a few hours, the problem was fixed. Austin had his financial aid back. He got the scholarship he'd earned.
BIRTUL: And that day, they applied the scholarship. And I remember sitting in the office and like my price of college went from astronomically high to like - to very affordable. And I looked at my mom, and my mom was crying. We actually went from the financial aid office to the office where you can pay for your tuition. And we paid that day (laughter).
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
VEDANTAM: Austin got to Georgia State University in the fall, just as he planned. He decided to major in political science. He's studying, living in Atlanta, still looking at those skyscrapers as he walks across campus.
A few months later, Austin was hanging out with his mom when he got a phone call. The person on the other end of the line says she was with the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. She asked him about the chatbot, whether he'd used it, how it helped him and so on.
BIRTUL: And she said, OK, so the Bill Gates Foundation is going to be interested in doing an interview with you. And I looked at my mom, and I just like smiled. And then she was like, who is that? Who is that?
VEDANTAM: They were making a documentary about a number of initiatives that had been put in place in Georgia State. Austin did the interview. And then he was told two higher-ups from the foundation would be visiting the next day.
BIRTUL: And so I was just picturing two higher-up people, like a man and a woman coming in with a suit on or something. And 40 minutes before they leave on the last day, they say, oh, you're going to meet Bill Gates. And me and the three other students just look at each other, and we're like, what? (Laughter) And we were told, you can't tell anybody. You have to wait until a certain time and then you can tell people that you met Bill Gates for security reasons.
And so he comes in. He's extremely nice, extremely polite. He asked many questions. He was super curious about everything we were doing here at Georgia State. And at one point, I actually had to show him how to use the chatbot. And we were about to begin filming this part of the documentary. And I said, first off, sir, it's extremely humbling to explain a software to you.
VEDANTAM: Austin's mom thinks he's famous now. When he thinks about the role the intervention played in his life, he's not sure if it's the reason he ended up at college, but the chatbot did mean that he sorted out the problem in time. He didn't have to jump through hoops or take a semester off while he waited for his financial aid.
BIRTUL: It was most instrumental because of the timing of it. If I'd ended up having - there's this whole strategy that one person told me about through the system where it was like, well, maybe you'd have to drop your classes and then just re-pick them up and you'd get FAFSA. And that wouldn't have been an option for me. I did not want to - I didn't want to be delayed in my education. So it was really instrumental because of this timing. And it was most important because it led to it coming at the time it needed to.
VEDANTAM: The researchers Lindsay Page and Ben Castleman think that small interventions like this - relatively cheap and simple to pull off - could make a difference for some of the kids who aren't making it through that critical summer window.
PAGE: If these are kids who have intentions to go to college, they are ready to go to college, and we can with low-cost supports improve the rates with which they successfully transition to college on time, then those are certainly dollars well spent.
VEDANTAM: But Ben Castleman and Lindsay Page have found in their research that some of the interventions intended to diminish summer melt might actually help students once they are in college. They teach students how to solve problems, navigate challenges.
The reason that kids drop off in the summer between high school and college is not because of any one big problem. It's a hundred little obstacles, like pebbles in your shoe - a financial aid form that requires a parent's signature. Easy enough, unless you have a parent who is sick or absent. A document asking students to make a decision about financial aid - easy enough if you have parents or a guidance counselor who can help. An important deadline - not hard to make unless you find yourself in a rural area without a car. Our society doesn't like these kinds of problems. But often, the difference between success and failure comes down to finding ways to remove each pebble from your shoe, often with small and unglamorous solutions like a chatbot. No one might win an award for it, but it can spell the difference between getting most of the way to a goal and crossing the finish line.
This episode of HIDDEN BRAIN was produced by Maggie Penman and edited by Tara Boyle. Our staff includes Rhaina Cohen, Jenny Schmidt, Renee Klahr, Parth Shah and Lucy Perkins. Our unsung hero this week is one of NPR's lawyers, Ashley Messenger. Whether it's ironing out the details of a contract for a music license or having a philosophical conversation about the nuances of media law, Ashley brings passion and intelligence to everything she does. Ashley, we're grateful for your savvy and your dedication. Thank you.
You can follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram and listen for my stories each week on your local public radio station. I'm Shankar Vedantam, and this is NPR.
Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.